What it is
Sets a concrete check on how the work, other people or their own earlier decisions are going, notices when something drifts, and corrects it. It is not checking everything all the time, and it is not looking over people's shoulders. It is one well-chosen check, at the right moment, followed by action. It includes the hardest case: noticing that your own earlier decision is not working and changing it.
What it looks like at work
- Set a concrete check
- Notice when something drifts
- Correct it
- Healthcare
A nurse rechecks a patient's pain an hour after a change of medicine and calls the doctor when it has not improved.
- Software
A software developer who released a fix watches the error rate that evening and rolls the change back when the errors rise.
- Finance
An accountant compares spending against the budget every week and flags one line that is running ahead before the quarter closes.
- Construction
A site manager walks the building site each afternoon against the plan and moves a crew when one task falls behind.
- Contact centre
A call-centre team lead listens to a sample of calls after a new script goes live and changes the part that confuses callers.
In each case the person decided in advance what to look at and when, noticed the drift, and did something about it.
Why it matters in different kinds of jobs
Plans drift. Patients respond differently than expected, projects slip, a new process creates a problem nobody foresaw. A small correction early is cheap; the same problem found at the end is expensive. Research on goals finds that monitoring progress helps people reach them (Harkin et al., 2016). Research on teams lists keeping track of progress as one of the core things teams do while they work (Marks, Mathieu & Zaccaro, 2001). An older, small study of managers found that the more effective ones spent more time checking how the work was going, often by looking at it directly (Komaki, 1986). Supervisors, project leads and quality roles need this most visibly, but so does anyone whose work continues after a decision: a nurse after a treatment, a developer after a release, an accountant after a forecast.
Why interviews often miss it
Interview stories jump from the plan to the outcome. The checking in between is invisible, because nothing dramatic happens when a check catches a problem early. Candidates also rarely volunteer stories about their own decisions that had to be reversed, which is exactly where this skill shows most.
How a work situation can show it
A realistic work situation can include something agreed earlier that starts to go off track, with early signs that are easy to miss. You then see whether the candidate sets or asks for a concrete check, notices the drift, and corrects it, including revising a decision they made themselves earlier in the situation.
What to ask in an interview
"Tell me about a decision of yours that you later had to change. How did you notice it was not working?"
Follow-up: "How long did it take you to act?"
"Describe how you keep track of a piece of work that other people are doing."
Follow-up: "Tell me about a time that check caught a problem."
"What is one check you now do routinely because something once went wrong?"
Listen for a concrete check (what, when), an early signal noticed, and a correction, including to the candidate's own decisions.
To see it with a situation from your own job, read how it works and pricing.
What hire.center shows, and its limits
In hire.center, a candidate handles one realistic work situation built from the job. The scorecard shows the candidate's own words for each skill the recruiter chose, or says there was not enough evidence. One situation shows one situation, not the whole job, and it does not test technical knowledge. A person makes the hiring decision. Our quality checks so far use AI-played candidates in six example jobs, most of them with customers or colleagues at the centre of the work. We are extending them to more kinds of jobs.
Sources
- Harkin, Webb, Chang, Prestwich, Conner, Kellar, Benn & Sheeran (2016). Does monitoring goal progress promote goal attainment? A meta-analysis of the experimental evidence. Psychological Bulletin, 142(2), 198–229
- Komaki (1986). Toward effective supervision: An operant analysis and comparison of managers at work. Journal of Applied Psychology, 71(2), 270–279
- Marks, Mathieu & Zaccaro (2001). A temporally based framework and taxonomy of team processes. Academy of Management Review, 26(3), 356–376
